Chad's Anger Management Training Chapter 42
by Chadlad

copyright 2006 by Chadlad, all rights reserved
chadlad3@yahoo.com

* * * * *
This story is intended for ADULTS ONLY It contains explicit
depictions of sexual activity involving minors. If you are
not of a legal age in your locality to view such material or
if such material does not appeal to you, do not read
further, and do not save this story.
* * * * *


Chapter 42:  Jimmy's Horsie Ride

Jimmy gaped at the horse.  It was already abundantly clear
what its purpose was.  His head would go there, with his
arms strapped to the horse's legs, and his legs would be
strapped on the other end, and the plastic mound would …. He
recoiled in horror.  "No," he said forcefully. "No, no, no,
no.  There's no way I'm getting strapped to that!  It'll
crush my balls!"

"Testes, Mr. Chen.  The proper word for those little marbles
of yours is testes.  But that's beside the point.  Young
man, you have a bad habit of voicing your opinions even when
they aren't relevant," Mrs. Rose said evenly.  "But since
you are going to be strapped to it, I'll explain some of its
finer points.  Naughty boys lie face down on the horse,
their heads here, and their legs here.  The center of the
horse and each of the legs can be lengthened and shortened
to accommodate a wide variety of sizes of boys, from the
very immature," (here she looked at Chad, "to the very
mature," (here, of course, she glanced at Joey).  "The boy's
arms and legs are strapped down with the restraints.  Notice
there is a pillow for the boy's head here," she said,
pointing to the far end of the device, "which is impervious
to tears, mucous, saliva, or any other disgusting fluids you
boys might produce when chastised.  This raised section,
back here," she said, pointing to the humped section over
the back legs, "is where the boy's crotch rests, with his
genitals on the hump.  The hump has been carefully
engineered to make it extremely uncomfortable for the boy
tied to the horse, as there is no position a boy can move to
that takes the weight of his bottom half off of his
genitals.  There is also an attachment available for use
with the genitals of girls, but the school did not have any
need to purchase that option, of course.  Once strapped
down, the boy is unable to move much, and any attempt to
avoid the spanking hand or the paddle will result in extreme
pressure on his sensitive genitals.  Thus, it's the perfect
spanking bench for situations where boys are so disobedient
that something more than a simple over the knee spanking or
paddling is called for."

She let this information sink in to the boys in the
classroom, then went on.  "You'll notice the horse is made
of carbon composites, so that it is light but also strong. 
Just as the pillow is impervious to saliva, tears, and
mucous, the other end of the horse is also impervious to any
materials that might come out of that end of a boy should he
lose control during a spanking or paddling, and it can be
hosed off afterward.  The horse is equipped with convenient
handles for lifting it and carrying it from place to place. 
It is light enough that four girls can move it by each
grabbing a leg, even with a boy still attached to it, as
long as the boy isn't too large and heavy, and for heavier
boys, there is room for 6 or 8 girls can team up to carry
him and it.  I'm told that riding it while being carried is
very uncomfortable as well, especially on the boy's genital
region."

She turned to Mrs. Hendricks.  "Could you be so good as to
bring the horse back here at around 11 o'clock, after you've
shown it to the other classes?" Mrs. Rose asked.  "We'll be
needing it for Mr. Chen at that time."  

Jimmy turned white as a sheet as Mrs. Hendricks nodded.  He
looked with a queasy feeling at the hard lump where his
prized genitals would soon be strapped, shuddering.  If he
could just learn to control his big mouth!

Mrs. Hendricks bustled out of the classroom, holding the
horse above her head as she maneuvered between the rows. 
Mrs. Rose looked at it admiringly.  "You have to appreciate
space age composites," she stated.  "Light as a feather,
strong as iron.  No boy's going to break that, no matter how
hard he thrashes."

She turned back to Jimmy.  "Now for our choice of spanking
implements.  Mr. Delvecchio certainly cried hard enough
yesterday when The Stinger was used on him, but today I'm in
the mood for something just as stingy but a little more old
fashioned.  Mr. Chen, I've decided you shall be whipped by
Miss Git on your bare bottom with a freshly-cut willow
switch from the tree outside!"

Jimmy gulped.  "How – How – How many do I get," he managed
to croak.

"I shall not be assigning you a particular number of blows,"
Mrs. Rose responded, "Because Miss Git is inexperienced with
the switch and might not make some of her strokes strong
enough, I'll simply have her switch you while I monitor her
progress, letting her continue until I think your bottom is
sufficiently welted, and you are crying sufficiently hard."

Jimmy's erect penis began shrinking like the air had gone
out of it.  He was gonna get whipped with a switch!  On his
bare bottom!  Tied to that awful horse thing!  He'd never
been switched before, even on the clothed butt, but he'd
heard stories.  He suddenly began dancing in place,
squeezing his small butt tightly.

"What's the matter now, Mr. Chen," Mrs. Rose asked.

"I'm sorry," Jimmy said.  "But I gotta pee bad!"  He clapped
both hands over his genitals.

"You're just frightened now that you've heard how you're
going to be punished," Mrs. Rose said firmly.  "It's just
fear -- you don't really have to go.  Now get your hands
behind our head and go stand in the center of the classroom
with your nose against the board."

Still dancing, Jimmy reluctantly complied.  Soon, he was in
the nose to the blackboard position, his small butt still
twitching and squeezing in greater and greater urgency as he
danced.  Mrs. Rose began describing the grading requirements
for the term paper due in two weeks.  In a few minutes,
Jimmy interrupted her again.  "I really gotta go, Mrs. Rose! 
Really!  I don't care if I gotta do it in front of everyone,
I really gotta go!"  Jimmy's butt was twitching like a pole
dancer's in a room full of dollar bills.

Mrs. Rose sighed, heading to her desk.  "Tape line," she
ordered laconically.  Jimmy raced to the line, his hands
still obediently behind his head, his penis fully extended
in pee urgency. Mrs. Rose plodded back with her jar, while
Jimmy tried to will her to hurry before he peed on the
floor.  Actually, he realized, with his penis pointing as it
was, it would be Emily and the girls behind her he'd pee on
– that might actually be funny, at least until he got
punished for that, too.  

Meanwhile, after a couple of tries where it slipped out as
she tried to catch it under the jar rim and point it
downward, Mrs. Rose finally succeeded in trapping Jimmy's
penis head under the rim of the jar, clearly visible through
the glass.  Jimmy, true to his word, didn't care that they
were watching, but peed powerfully into the jar, filling it
almost half full.  Mrs. Rose swiped the end of Jimmy's now
shrinking penis with a tissue and sent Joey to empty the
jar.  Jimmy was immediately dispatched to the front of the
room, where he was able to stand with a bit more decorum for
the next hour, shifting from foot to foot and occasionally
squeezing his bare butt in anticipation of the coming
whipping.  Finally, after working through the example math
exercises, Mrs. Rose ordered books to be put away.  

"Mr. Chen, tape line, please," she ordered.  Jimmy turned
and walked to the tape line, his erection once again
visible.  Mrs. Rose frowned.  "Still think this is exciting,
Mr. Chen?  We'll disabuse you of that silly notion and take
care of your ever-present erection all at once."  She turned
to Emily.  "Take Mr. Chen out to the willow tree in the
yard," she said, pointing out the window at the tree she had
in mind.  Emily nodded understanding.  She handed Emily a
pocket knife.  "Make him cut his own switches.  Have him cut
three, each about the width of a pencil.  We'll need extras
in case you break any of them over his naughty bottom.  Make
sure he cuts them himself.  Come right back here when you
have all three."  Emily nodded, grinning evilly as she
approached Jimmy, ready to grab his balls and milk them
during the trip outside.  

"Oh, and Emily," Mrs. Rose said pleasantly as the girl
approached Jimmy.  "Leave the boy's scrotum alone for now –
the horse will take care of it for us.  Lead him by his
penis to and from the yard."

Disappointed in not being able to grind the boy's balls
together at will to and from the tree, Emily gripped Jimmy's
still erect member and yanked it hard enough he thought she
was going to pull it out of him as she dragged him from the
room.  Mrs. Rose put everyone to work on the math practice
problems as she watched the two approach the tree, noting
that Emily kept her grip on the boy's penis as she handed
him the knife and pointed out various branches.  Jimmy
appeared reluctant to cut the implements that would be used
on his own bare bottom and even more reluctant, once they'd
been cut, to carry them.  He held the three switches at
arm's length as he was led by painful tugs of his erect
member back to the building, glancing at them from time to
time and flinching.  Moments later they were back in the
classroom.

Emily reluctantly released Jimmy's now only half hard penis
and he stood on the tape line, watching with fascinated
dread as Mrs. Rose peeled the bark from each switch and
waved each in the air, testing their flex and heft.  She
lined the three up in a row on her desk.  "This one first, I
think," she said, pointing to the end switch.  "Then this
one, and if necessary, this one," she added, pointing out
the other two in order.  "You did an excellent job of
choosing switches, Emily.  These should really sting young
Mr. Chen's bottom."

Jimmy's butt twitched, as if he could feel the switches
hitting him already.  Several girls giggled as his sausage
penis bounced in response.

"Come up here, Emily.  While we're waiting for the horse,"
Mrs. Rose said, "I'll give you some instruction in how to
properly switch a boy on his bare bottom.  The key to
switching a boy is to land the blows as well-aligned with
the plane of the muscles as possible, so that at least the
upper third or so of the switch makes contact at once.  This
creates a line of contact that stings quite painfully along
its entire extent, but doesn't break the skin as would
happen if only the end of the switch hit first.  The
accepted procedure is to stand to one side of the boy and
cover both sides of his bottom with lines from that side,
holding the switch at an angle and striking downward so that
the lines are slanted and cover more of his bottom that way. 
Then you move to the boy's other side and switch it exactly
the same way, so that the lines cross-cross each other.  The
pain where the lines cross each other is excruciating, if
the reactions of the boys I've punished this way in the past
are any indication.  The resulting painful welts are one of
the better deterrent properties of this particular type of
paddling."  

Jimmy's butt contracted involuntarily again as she said
"painful welts," making his plump penis jump and bringing
more laughter from the class.  Mrs. Rose waited for quiet,
then continued.  "If Mr. Chen's disobedience makes it
necessary, you may have to use a third technique, where you
stand directly over his lower back and bring the switch
straight down between his buttocks, so that the boy's
perineum, anus, or even his scrotum may be switched.  Mr.
Chen, you should be warned that anything less than your
complete obedience will not be tolerated, and that I'll
direct Emily to switch you in the center between your
buttocks if I deem it necessary."  

Jimmy swayed, looking as if he might pass out.  Did she just
say they might switch his asshole and his balls if he didn't
behave while being whipped?  His penis drooped dramatically,
the tip pointing at the floor in moments.  He was so
frightened that if he'd been wearing pants he'd have been in
danger of pooping them. As is was, he had to tighten his
butt and anal sphincter as much as he could, going up on his
toes as he controlled his system, and it was a close thing
for moment before his body settled down again. 

Just then the classroom door opened, and Mrs. Hendricks
returned, carrying the horse easily over her head.  "Sorry
I'm a bit late, Mrs. Rose," she said.  "You have the only
boy in the upper 4 grades already in need of the horse this
morning for discipline, but we had to strap a boy into it in
each classroom as a demonstration of its discomfort
properties and that took a bit of time."  She smiled grimly. 
"I had each of the teachers pick the boy they thought most
likely to need the horse soon, and made each of them strip
from the waist down like Mr. Chen here and allow themselves
to be strapped in.  We made them each stay at least 10
minutes, so they could appreciate its possibilities better. 
I'm afraid that all took a bit of time."

"That's quite all right, Mrs. Hendricks," Mrs. Rose replied. 
"We were just now ready for you, anyway.  I hope you can
stay for the horse's inaugural test," she added.

"Of course," Mrs. Hendricks said.  "Few aspects of my job
are more important than maintaining discipline among these
unruly boys.  I'll just sit over here," she added, settling
herself in the visitor's chair near Mrs. Rose's desk.  Mrs.
Rose arranged the horse about 5 feet in front of the tape
line, so that the head was near the blackboard, and the back
end was facing Emily's seat.  "Mr. Chen, stand to one side
for a moment, please.  I'd like Emily to have some practice
with the switch before we start."

She went to the closet, retrieving the "practice butt" the
children had seen the day before, arranging it straddling
the end of the horse and buckling the two Velcro thigh
straps around its stumps.  The imitation boy butt faced the
class, its stitched in anus looking like a big asterisk. 
Mrs. Rose arranged Emily close by the side of the horse,
showing her the proper angle for making  reasonably flat
contact with the rounded mounds of the target.  On her cue,
Emily brought the switch down with a quite scary swishing
sound, raising a bit of dust as the switch landed with a
loud "whap!"  Jimmy's bottom flinched as he saw and heard
the contact, and his eyes bugged.

"Excellent!"  Mrs. Rose said.  "Just make it a bit flatter
as it lands, and try to get the center of the buttock more
than just the sides.  Another few loud swishes and
resounding whaps satisfied Mrs. Rose, who then shifted Emily
to the other side and had her practice matching blows from
that side.  Jimmy, Chad noticed, was flinching more and
squeezing his butt more tightly together with each swing. 
His eyes were bugging out in fear as well, and he looked
deathly pale.  When Mrs. Rose positioned Emily directly over
the horse and had her swing downward into the practice
butt's butt crack, his knees became rubbery and he began
swaying dangerously.  Mrs. Rose noticed his weakness in the
knees and walked to his side to steady him.  "That's enough
practice," she said.  "You're ready.  It's time for Mr. Chen
to find out life isn't just making fun and smart remarks."

Jimmy was guided over on shaking, unsteady legs to the end
of the horse and faced away from them, then forced down onto
his stomach onto the cross board.  Mrs. Rose spread his legs
onto the top sides of the horse's own legs, then reached
quickly between them and arranged his soft penis against his
stomach, so that he was resting on both it and his scrotum. 
Quickly, before he could move and free it, Mrs. Rose
strapped his thighs and calves tightly with Velcro, then
extended each of his arms and strapped them tightly at the
wrists.  Chad noticed immediately that Jimmy's feet didn't
reach the bottom of the legs, so all his weight was indeed
on his genitals.  Verifying that, Jimmy immediately began
shifting his butt back and forth uncomfortably, his scrotum
bulging backward between his legs and pressing on the bulge
on either one side or the other no matter which way he
shifted.  "It hurts my privates," he complained. 

"That's the point," Mrs. Rose said calmly.  "Now be quiet
and try not to be a baby during your punishment.  The number
of blows you'll get in the center, if any, depends upon your
deportment from this point onward."

Jimmy clamped his mouth shut, biting his lip.  His balls
already ached badly, and his dick was uncomfortable all
along the underside, where his weight was on it.  He could
feel the unnatural feeling of open air on his butt hole, his
butt crack, and the skin between his legs.  He knew everyone
was looking right up his butt crack, seeing his butt hole
and everything.  He felt so open and vulnerable.  She could
just hit him anywhere with that nasty switch!  His left nut
was aching unbearably so he shifted his butt.  His right nut
immediately began aching instead.  This was going to be
torture, and his switching hadn't even started yet!

Mrs. Rose addressed him.  "Jimmy Chen, you have showed
disrespect for the rules of this school by arriving in class
late, by making flippant remarks, and by repeatedly
displaying inappropriate arousal when threatened with
punishment.  Accordingly, under the rules established by the
school board, you shall be punished by being whipped with a
switch on your bare bottom by a female classmate until your
bottom has been sufficiently lined that I feel you have
learned your lesson.  Then you will remain on the horse
until after lunch.  You will be carried to the lunch room on
the horse and spend lunch time strapped to it as an example
to the other boys in this school.  After lunch you will be
removed from the horse and spend the rest of the day sitting
on the punishment chair naked in the corner, as per school
policy.  Do you have anything to say in your defense before
I insert your underpants in your mouth as a gag and your
punishment is carried out?"

Jimmy couldn't stop himself.  It was the perfect straight
line.  
"Yes!"  he blurted, before he'd really thought it through. 
"MY BALLS ARE KILLING ME!"  The class erupted into raucous
laughter, Joey laughing so hard he fell out of his chair.

Mrs. Rose colored in anger.  "Whip the impudent brat," she
said to Emily loudly, over the noise.  "Put the stripes as
close together as you can.  Cover his whole bottom from both
sides, and then I'll have you do the center thoroughly as
well."

"Nooooooooooo!" Jimmy wailed, suddenly aware his mouth had
gotten the better of him again.  "Noooooooo, I didn't mean
it!  I'm sorrrrrrrrry!"  His cries were choked off as his
underpants were jammed into his open mouth by the ever
resourceful Mrs. Rose.  Jimmy had only a moment to worry
about whether he'd put on clean ones that morning, and then
it was too late for regrets.  The air whistled, and then a
searing line of pain bloomed high on his right buttock,
followed swiftly by one next to it, and then one next to it,
and then one more below it, as Emily grimly covered his
right buttock with stripes.  She was striking him about once
very 4 seconds, so it took her almost a minute of searing,
unimaginable, ever-mounting pain to reach the bottom of his
right buttock and move her aim to the top of the left.  

The class watched in amazement as Jimmy's butt muscles
squeezed impotently on their own, his flesh dancing but his
butt remaining bent and spread, the horse restricting his
movements.  Within seconds after each lash landed, a red
line appeared on Jimmy's bottom and rose up above the
surface.  Most also had a larger raised welt where the tip
of the switch had struck.  Jimmy couldn't control his
squeezing buttocks despite the fact that each movement
caused waves of aching pain from where his sensitive balls
made contact with the hard plastic bulge of the horse.  The
searing pain that kept blooming across a wider and wider
area of his bottom was incredible – he'd been spanked many,
many times before and even paddled, both at home and at
school, but never felt a switch on his bare flesh before. 
He hollered full force into his gag, but his screams emerged
as low moans through the tightly packed cloth. 

Once Emily had laid 12 strokes on each plump cheek of
Jimmy's shivering, quaking butt, Mrs. Rose stayed her hand
and shifted her to his right hand side.  Then she began
again, laying out 12 matching strokes slanting downward on
each of his buttocks from that side, the stripes criss-
crossing the previous ones.  Where each strip crossed a
previous one, a prominent bright red and almost square welt
immediately appeared.  Jimmy's butt began contracting more
violently, his flesh rippling and shaking with each blow. 
It's like a fleshquake, Chad that thought to himself. 
Jimmy's butt hole also trembled and twitched, contracting
and winking at them continuously.  Chad and every other boy
in the room looked on, each of them feeling so very, very
glad it wasn't them being switched.  

The girls were less sympathetic.  "Someone get a marker – I
want to play tic-tac-toe," Karla cracked.  

"Or maybe checkers," Lindsay contributed.  "You'd just have
to watch out for that trap in the center of the board – it
might swallow up your king!"

Even through the underpants gag, Jimmy was loud.  By the
time the final stroke landed on his right bun from the left
side, his whole body was flushed, and tears running down off
the vinyl pillow and down the legs of the horse had formed
two irregular puddles on the floor.  Snot from his nose
coated the vinyl pillow and was rubbed all over his wildly
twisting face as he moved the only part of his body that was
really free.  He was inhaling in gasps through his nose and
squalling through the gag as he exhaled.  His whole world
was his butt and his genitals – he couldn't feel anything
else but lines of white hot pain on his butt and the
throbbing ache of hissquashed balls.

There was pause as Emily shifted position to directly over
top of his spread butt, and then Jimmy discovered there were
other parts to his body besides his butt.  A line of fire
bloomed from his anus all they down his crack to the base of
his balls.  He screamed into the gag, only to feel a second
and then a third blow land on either side of the first.  The
tip of the switch nicked Jimmy's scrotum as Emily made the
third line, causing a spot of blood to appear.  Every muscle
in Jimmy's body was tensed, as he tested mightily the
strength of his bonds.  Then he collapsed, blowing snot from
his nose with each breath.  At the termination of Emily's
third blow up the middle, Mrs. Rose took her hand, shaking
her head mightily as Emily shifted her angle so that the
next blow would have involved the tip of the switch landing
right on Jimmy's prominently projecting left testicle.  She
pried the switch from the girl's tightly gripping fingers. 
"You've done enough, Emily," she said loudly.  "I believe
you should sit down now."

Jimmy had become a beaten animal with the last three blows,
bellowing squeal after squeal into his gag but sagging
defeated on the horse.  Mrs. Rose pointedly ignored his
distress, putting down the switch on her desk and taking up
the baby wipes, which she used to wipe down his welted
bottom and his scarred butt crack.  She then walked between
him and the classroom and speaking loudly to be heard over
his muffled moans.

"While we're waiting for Mr. Chen to stop his histrionics,"
she said, "I want each of you to take out a paper and pen
and write a 5 paragraph argumentative paper.  Be sure to use
an introductory paragraph, three argument paragraphs, and a
conclusion paragraph.  In this paper, you should choose a
form of punishment that would even more effective on a 13-
year-old boy than the switch you just saw demonstrated. 
Describe just what that punishment would be, and then argue
why it would be an even more effective form of punishment
than the switch on a boy's bare bottom."  She glanced back
at the red-striped bottom of the still bawling Jimmy Chen,
then continued.  "You may use anything you've learned from
experiences in the classroom over the last few days or from
you own experience to support of your arguments.  You have
until lunch time to complete your papers."

She paused a moment, and then added, "Remember, your
arguments have to be convincing.  If you try to argue that
grounding a boy is more effective than whipping his bare
bottom, for example, your paper will undoubtedly receive a
very low score. If you want a passing grade, you have to
make your arguments convince me.  Girls failing to write a
convincing essay may very well receive detention.  And you
boys may experience the switch on your own bare bottoms if I
sense you're trying to make a mockery of this assignment."

All over the classroom, children groaned and began
retrieving paper from their desks and staring into space
looking thoughtful.  Jimmy continued howling into his gag,
his twitching bottom still in continuous motion, his arms
and legs still pulling feebly at the bonds of the horse. 
Chad chewed the end of his pen for a moment, frowning and
looking at the angry stripes criss-crossing Jimmy Chen's
bottom and running down the center of his butt crack.  He
had to think of something she'd believe he really hated
worse than being whipped, but he didn't want to give her any
ideas of more horrible punishments, especially punishments
that might be used on him.  An idea suddenly struck him.  He
leaned over his desk, writing in his somewhat childish
scrawl:

In this paper, I will begin by agreeing that the switch on
the bare bottom is a very effective form of punishment for
boys.  This is because the switch is so thin that it can get
almost anywhere, even all the way in between a boy's buns to
hit his poo hole or the bag his testes are in.

Chad frowned as he finished the last line.  Even since Tommy
had mocked him when he'd used the phrase "poo hole" in
describing his nether orifice, he felt wrong whenever he
thought or used the phrase.  But he was in a bind here – he
couldn't remember the adult word for the place the poo came
out right at the moment, and he knew he didn't dare write
"asshole," in a paper Mrs. Rose would read.  It wouldn't be
safe to say "butt hole" either.  He racked his brain for the
word, but it wouldn't come to him. It was something like
Amos or Avis, but he couldn't quite retrieve it.  He
shrugged and went on.

But even though a switching is a very effective form of
punishment for boys, I will argue that there are forms of
punishment that are even more effective than even switching
a boy on his poo hole.  In particular, I will argue that
making a boy suck another boy's privates or lick his butt in
front of others is more effective than even a whipping with
a switch on his poo hole or testes.

Chad read over his paragraph. He wondered if he should have
said butt hole instead.  Oh well, it was too late to change,
now.  He went into his argument paragraphs:

The first reason I think that having a boy suck another
boy's privates or lick his butt in front of others is a more
effective punishment is that it lasts longer.  When you whip
a boy, his butt hurts real bad for awhile, but in a day or
so it heals up and he forgets about how much it hurt.  But
when a boy has to suck another boy's privates or lick his
butt and everyone sees it, every time he comes to class
he'll see the people who watched him and remember them
watching him do it, and get humiliated all over again.

Chad reread this.  So far, so good, he thought.  He chewed
his pencil thoughtfully and went on:

The second reason I think that having a boy suck another
boy's privates or lick his butt in front of others is a more
effective punishment is that it is truly, truly disgusting
to have to lick another boy's butt.  This is especially true
if the boy has to clean something off of the other boy's
butt when licking it, like chocolate syrup.  The syrup gets
into the wrinkles in his poo hole and into the center, and
the boy would have to lick real hard and deep to get it out,
which would be disgusting.

Chad looked up at Jimmy's cross-hatched butt and thought
some more.  Jimmy's butt was still twitching, and Chad could
see welts on the boy's butt hole itself.  Owwww, he thought
idly.  And I thought I'd had it bad when I got paddled! 
Mrs. Rose approached Jimmy as he watched with more baby
wipes in her hand.  She seized his head and pulled it back
from the horse, then began vigorously scrubbing the snot off
of Jimmy's face, while he protested feebly.  Chad looked at
his paper again, another idea coming to him.  He wrote:

The third reason I think that having a boy suck another
boy's privates or lick his butt in front of others is a more
effective punishment is that all his friends will think he's
a queer, and then they'll bug him all the time to suck them,
too, maybe even for years afterward.  Besides, boys pee out
of their penises and poop out of their poo holes, and having
to put your mouth those places would be a bad punishment for
any boy.

There, Chad thought.  She'll buy that.  He hoped he wasn't
giving her new punishment ideas for him or the other boys,
but he had to write something, or he'd risk getting spanked
himself.  Besides, he bet she'd already thought of this one
– after all, his other and Mrs. Delvecchio had.  He quickly
wrote his final paragraph.

So that's why I think that having a boy suck another boy's
privates or lick his butt is a more humiliating and
effective punishment than just whipping his butt and his
butt crack.  It lasts longer, it's really disgusting, and
other boys will tease him for it forever.  All this things
make it worse than a bare butt whipping.

Chad wrote his name with a flourish on the top of his paper
and looked up.  Many other children were still writing.  His
wasn't bad, he thought.  It ought to at least sound sincere,
and it wasn't nearly as bad as other punishments that he
could think of, such as getting a paddling on the balls, or
having a lit candle rammed up his butt and having to hold it
there like Alan had experienced.  

He looked Jimmy's spread butt and legs, all of him that
could really be seen because his head was facing to his
right at the moment.  Jimmy was slowly quieting down, his
butt now twitching only slightly and his squeals merely low
moans.  

Chad shivered at the three red lines running right down the
center of the boy's crack, puffy weals running right across
his butt hole, and three bright red welts bulging just above
his sack, which was squashed uncomfortably against the
raised bump on the horse. Chad shook his head. He'd lied in
his paper, of course.  He knew from his own experience the
last few days that sucking a boy's penis, or even multiple
boys' penises in a row, didn't hold a candle to being tied
to the horse and getting what Jimmy had just gotten.